Ethereum security initiativeDraft proposal. Not submitted.
Impact
What we will measure, starting from zero.
Every milestone has a test. An independent reviewer, named before work starts, runs it. Until that reviewer confirms, nothing counts and nothing is paid.
Paid so far: $0 of $100,000 proposed
ProposedDraft proposal. Targets are proposed. Nothing on this page counts work that has not happened.
- MilestoneM1What is measuredThe four-layer method, payment rules and gap-only rules, publishedWhat countsThe reviewer reruns the demo script at the pinned commits and gets the same function inventory.TodayNot yet checked by a reviewerReleases$12,000
- MilestoneM2What is measuredFour-layer reviews of open-source mainnet protocols, completed and publishedWhat countsEach record matches its reviewed commit and its payment records.TodayNone yetTarget: Three or moreReleases$28,000
- MilestoneM3What is measuredGap-only follow-ups after real upgrades, and accepted outside evidence itemsWhat countsA follow-up lists the change set it covered. An evidence item counts after two independent reviewers release it.TodayNone yetTarget: Three or more follow-upsTarget: 250 evidence itemsReleases$20,000
- MilestoneM4What is measuredOutside protocols above the value bar that publish a review recordWhat countsThe protocol holds more than $100 million on Ethereum mainnet at the pinned block, by the published read-only query.TodayNone yetTarget: Three or moreReleases$40,000Adoption
Empty boxes are targets. None is filled yet.
01Measured in public
The measures
| Measure | Today | Proposed target | How it is checked | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Released audits on the public explorerLive | 0 | Every funded review released | Reviewer reads the explorer and each release record | Public explorer, read now |
| Protocols analyzed, and their stateLive |
| — | Explorer state per protocol | Public explorer, read now |
| Four-layer reviews completed and publishedProposed | None yet | Three or more (M2) | Published records checked against the reviewed commit | No public four-layer review exists yet. |
| Gap-only follow-ups publishedProposed | None yet | Three or more (M3) | Records list the change set they covered | — |
| Accepted outside evidence itemsProposed | Program not started | 250 (M3) | Public list of accepted items and their two reviewers | — |
| Researchers paid through the initiativeProposed | None yet | Every funded review | Payment records shared with the reviewer under confidentiality | — |
| Outside protocols above the value bar that adoptedProposed | None yet | Three or more (M4) | Reviewer reruns the value-bar query at the pinned block | Method below |
| Snap available in ordinary MetaMaskLive | Checking install status | — (depends on MetaMask) | MetaMask's public allowlist | Proof of Audits runtime config, read now |
We do not show the auditor leaderboard here. Its profiles are imported from public contest records and are not outcomes of this initiative.
02The value bar
How we tell a real adopter from a small one
An adopting protocol must hold more than the value bar on Ethereum mainnet at a fixed block. A read-only script measures this. It sends only read calls, prices each token with Chainlink feeds read at the same block, and checks each feed's description and token symbol onchain.
Value bar: $100 million, measured at a pinned block.
The method, tested on three protocols at block 26,378,312
| Protocol (analyzed, not adopters) | What was measured | Lower bound at block 26,378,312 |
|---|---|---|
| Aave V4 Spoke | Supplied assets reported by the Spoke | $347,249,974, plus 6 reserves the query could not price |
| Morpho Blue | Token balances held by the singleton contract | $2,296,489,149 |
| Uniswap V3 | Balances of 9 pools found through the factory | $317,137,108 |
Source: Proof of Audits value-bar query, run 12 November 2026 against block 26,378,312 with 157 read calls. These protocols are case studies used to test the method. They are not adopters, partners or customers.
Still to decide: for lending markets, whether the bar uses token balances held or the assets the protocol itself reports as supplied. The table shows the measure used for each case.
What would not count as impact
- 01Page views, sign-ups or wallet connections.
- 02Reviews of code that is not deployed on Ethereum mainnet.
- 03Records released by Proof of Audits staff alone, without the two independent reviewers the release rule requires.
- 04Protocols below the value bar, for the adoption milestone. Their reviews still count for Milestones 2 and 3.
- 05Anything produced only by AI.
Read the proposal
This page is updated from the public explorer each time it loads. When the first funded review is published it appears in the first row.